This article has been updated here: Pragmatism
“But what do you actually have to do?”
“You have to implement this solution.”
“Yes, but what do I do?”
“You have to implement this solution.”
“How? Who do I have to speak to? What should I say?”
I seem to have these conversations all the time. It’s fine being a visionary, but somewhere along the line someone has to actually do something. Like the old shop notice said: “The impossible we do at once. Miracles take a little longer.”
The interesting thing, though, is that nobody likes a pragmatist. Or, rather, they do, except when it’s they who are being pressured. That’s not a criticism, only an observation. I’m as guilty of that behaviour as anyone else: I hate it when someone says, “Yes, but…”. What right do they have to put practical issues before such a wonderful vision, before my brilliant idea?
I think ICT (education technology) especially lends itself to flights of fancy that come adrift from their moorings (if they were ever attached in the first place). We get carried away with the possibilities, but forget the down-to-earth stuff. For example, how many interactive whiteboard-equipped classrooms have a lockable cupboard in which the whiteboard pens and other accessories may be stored safely? Or, to take another example, how come many new schools are built as open plan areas, and end up having walls put in afterwards in order to block out the noise from one class “room” to another? Anyone contemplating having such a design implemented need simply to find some people who were educated in Britain in the 1970s (a trawl through Friends United ought to yield some potentially useful contacts), when open plan was all the rage, and ask them how they found it. Open plan may look great, and may lend itself to inter-class collaboration, but on a real, down-to-earth basis, the noise contamination can completely spoil it. But why let a practical matter like that get in the way of a good idea?
Going back to the opening paragraph of this article, it’s good to have a vision for ICT, but you also need a strategy whereby the vision will come into being. It’s no good hoping for a miracle. You’ll make yourself unpopular by asking questions like “what?”, “How?”, “Who”; but if you really believe in the vision, what choice do you have?
Related articles
In ICT, the past is not what it was (ictineducation.org)
I don't know the author of the cartoon. If you have any information about its source, please let me know so that I may accredit it properly. Thank you.
